Posted on 2026-03-12
When to Repair vs Replace Your Bath Taps
Leaking or stiff bath taps are a common complaint. Should you repair what you have or replace with new? Here's how to decide, along with costs for each option.
When repair is the right choice
Simple fixes first
If your bath taps are dripping, the fix is usually a new washer or ceramic cartridge. For traditional taps with separate hot and cold handles, replacing a washer costs around £50-£80 per tap. For modern quarter-turn or mixer taps, a replacement ceramic cartridge costs £60-£120. These repairs take under an hour and are worthwhile if your taps are in good condition and you like the style.
When taps are stiff or hard to turn
Stiff taps are usually caused by limescale buildup inside the mechanism or worn spindle O-rings. A plumber can usually disassemble the tap, clean or replace the internal parts, and reassemble for £50-£100 per tap. In Poole and other hard water areas, limescale is the most common cause of stiff taps. Consider fitting scale inhibitors if this is a recurring problem.
When replacement makes more sense
Age and condition
If your bath taps are over 15 years old, replacement parts may be difficult or impossible to source. Cross-top and pillar taps from the 1990s and earlier use specific washer sizes and valve types that aren't always available. If the tap body itself is corroded, pitted, or the chrome is peeling, no amount of internal repair will make them function well. At that point, replacement is the better investment.
Cost comparison
Repairing a pair of bath taps in Poole costs £100-£200. Replacing with new taps costs £150-£350 including fitting (less if you supply your own taps). The difference is often only £50-£150, and you get brand new taps with a manufacturer warranty. Modern bath taps also offer better water efficiency, ceramic disc valves that don't drip, and easier operation.
Choosing new bath taps
Tap types explained
Bath pillar taps (separate hot and cold) are the traditional choice and fit standard bath holes. Bath mixer taps combine hot and cold into one tap body, giving you better temperature control. Bath shower mixers add a shower attachment to the mixer. Freestanding bath taps are mounted on the floor beside the bath. Your choice depends on your bath type, existing pipework, and personal preference. Your Poole plumber can advise on what works with your setup.
What to check before buying
Before buying new bath taps, check: the number of tap holes in your bath (1, 2, or 3), the distance between holes if there are two (the 'centres'), and the thread size of the existing connections. Take a photo and measurements to the shop. If you're changing from pillar taps to a mixer tap, your plumber may need to modify the pipework slightly, which adds £30-£50 to the fitting cost.
Getting your bath taps done in Poole
DIY or professional?
Changing a tap washer is a manageable DIY job if you're comfortable with basic tools and can isolate the water supply. Full tap replacement is more involved and usually better left to a plumber, especially on baths where access to the pipework underneath is tight. Getting it wrong risks water damage. A professional will also test the installation and check for leaks before leaving.
How we can help
Our Poole plumbers repair and replace bath taps every day. We carry common washers, cartridges, and connectors on every van. For replacements, you can supply your own taps or we can source them. We provide a clear quote before starting, and Premium Home Members receive a 365-day guarantee on all work. Call us on 01202 544 101 for a free, no-obligation quote.